6 Followers
15 Following
memdash

M—

Newbie switchover from Goodreads, presently feeling out this site.

Year of the Cat - Carroll Bryant This book came into my awareness when I was directed to this review:

http://caedyslibrary.blogspot.com/2012/12/review-year-of-cat-by-carroll-bryant.html

The review is not particularly notable, it's a short I-did-not-enjoy-this-book-and-here-is-why, and if I had encountered this review and nothing more, I would have thought, 'Huh, that book doesn't sound like my taste. I don't think I'll read it.'

What is notable is that the author of the book left a comment on the review accusing the reviewer of various flavors of dishonesty. I don't consider such comments a bad thing, in and of themselves — there is certainly plenty of historical precedent with authors or actors or what-have-you writing pointed and scathing responses to critics (example) — but there's a world of difference between sending off a letter to the editor and posting a comment in a minor social blog. I feel at best Bryant's comments were in poor taste and at worse they were unprofessional.

Regardless of Bryant's intentions, his exchange has formed my private opinion that I do not wish to ever give this author any of my money, or anything further of my time.